Satisfy Your Pizza Craving at Fire N The Hole Wood Fired Pizza

My first exposure to Fire N The Hole Wood Fired Pizza took place at the Kosciusko County Fair as I scoured the grounds for places to eat. You couldn’t help but notice them. Encamped at the front entrance of the fair, their huge lumber-filled furnace pumped out sweet smelling scents to passersby like the sirens to the sailors in Homer’s Odyssey. It lured me in and while the pizza was delicious, I swore off Fire N The Hole after that first experience. The young lady who took my order was unpleasant at best and to top it off, they charged me (I think a couple bucks) for the box without telling me that there would be a charge. It didn’t matter how good the pizza was – I was turned off and done with Fire N The Hole.
Luckily for me, Fire N The Hole opened a new “permanent” location just south of downtown Warsaw so I was able to avoid the fair fiasco. A few bites into their pizza and I was willing to let bygones be bygones. When they opened their second spot in the old Schoop’s location, we headed over there and I gave the ordering process another go. It was the complete opposite of the unfortunate fair incident. The lady who took our order was very friendly, there was no charge for the boxes (probably absorbed into the price for the pizza) and the guy baking the pizza in the wood fire oven couldn’t have been nicer. If you’ve been wondering about checking out Fire N The Hole Pizza, don’t wonder any longer. Their tasty pizza varieties, which range from $8 – $12, include their Breakfast Pizza (sausage gravy, hash browns, scrambled eggs, bacon and cheddar), the Horsin’ Around (prime rib, onions, horsey sauce, mashed potatoes, cheese blend and portabella mushrooms) and their Just What the Doctor Ordered (Tuscan EVOO, roma, fresh basil, prosciutto, sliced pear, parmesan and fresh mozzarella). Standards are offered as well with the Extreme (supreme version), All Meat and Cheese. Did I mention the Bacon Cheeseburger one? Goodness. I don’t know what wood firing does to a pizza but I know what comes out of that oven is amazing and worth your money. The customer service and pricing issues I had with them from the “fair incident” are a distant memory. The only regret I now have is that I wrote them off for way too long. Each scrumptious bite is a reminder of that and I feel obligated to drown my guilt in a mouthful of their pizza. I think I can work with that.
My favorite, the Horsin’ Around
The Jalapeno Popper!
Find out more about Fire N The Hole Wood Fired Pizzas including their menu and contact info to book them for fundraising or private events. You can currently find them in the parking lot of the old Schoop’s restaurant and at the southeast corner of Buffalo and Winona next to TCU. Both locations are in Warsaw.Tags: fire n the hole, indiana, warsaw

Categories

Places to Eat

Places to Stay

Beaches & Lakes

La Cantina Brings Big Flavor and Even Bigger Vibes to Warsaw

We stopped into La Cantina Latin Bar & Grill in Warsaw the other night, and it turned out to be exactly the kind of spot you hope to find when you want good drinks, big flavors, and zero stress. The place is one wide-open space with plenty of room to breathe, a solid...

Blue Apron to Reopen Thursday, October 23, with Limited Menu

Press Release WARSAW, IN — The Warsaw Area Career Center (WACC) is excited to announce the reopening of The Blue Apron, a student-operated restaurant led by culinary team Mr. Craig Streby, Mr. Eric Jacko and Miss Victoria Heinsman. This year, thirty-one new and...

One Ten Craft Meatery Announces Its Final Service After a Decade of Culinary Excellence

After an incredible decade of culinary innovation, One Ten Craft Meatery has announced that Saturday, October 11, 2025, will mark its final evening of regular dinner service. In a heartfelt Facebook post, owner Jason Brown shared the bittersweet news, thanking the...

Strut Your Stuff: Downtown Warsaw Fashion Weekend Brings Style to the Streeets

Hey Noshers, clear your social calendars. This weekend, downtown Warsaw transforms into a runway you can stroll. The Downtown Warsaw Fashion Weekend is back, and it’s serving up style, swagger, and serious people-watching. Here’s what you can expect (and how to play...

Explore the Historic Kosciusko County Courthouse: A Must-See Landmark in Warsaw, Indiana

If you’re looking for things to do in Kosciusko County, Indiana, a visit to the Kosciusko County Courthouse in downtown Warsaw is an absolute must. This beautiful and historic building isn’t just a place for county business; it’s a fascinating landmark that offers a...

La Troje in Warsaw Now Slings the Area’s Best Margaritas … To Go

Big news, margarita fans: La Troje in Warsaw is now offering their legendary margs to go. Yes, you read that right—fully mixed, perfectly balanced, ready-to-drink margaritas you can take home. No need to fumble with a bottle of tequila, triple sec, and a questionable...

A New Chapter in Winona Lake: The River Coffeehouse Takes Over Light Rail Cafe

Winona Lake’s vibrant dining and coffee scene is about to see an exciting change! After 12 years of serving up delicious pizzas, sandwiches, and coffee, Light Rail Cafe announced on their Facebook page (https://www.facebook.com/lightrailcafewl) that they are...

Oku Roji Announces Closure as The River Coffeehouse Expands

Warsaw’s beloved Oku Roji is closing its doors temporarily as of November 16th, marking an exciting new chapter for the downtown dining and social scene. This cozy, basement-level restaurant has quickly become a local favorite for its Japanese-inspired dishes and hip...

Nine Must-Visit Places to Eat in Warsaw and Winona Lake

  Nine Must-Visit Places to Eat in Warsaw and Winona Lake Looking for great places to eat in Warsaw and Winona Lake? You're in for a treat! Our local food scene offers a variety of flavors that will satisfy every craving. From sushi to pizza to Mexican food and...

Coffee for a Cause – Generous Coffee Brews Up Change in Downtown Warsaw

  Generous Coffee Brews Up Change in Downtown Warsaw: A New Café with a Heart If you’re a coffee enthusiast like me, you’re always on the lookout for the next great cup of joe. But what if your morning coffee could do more than just wake you up? What if it could...
Buy me a coffee!